"Shipping goods but not getting paid" is the most worrying thing in foreign trade. Choosing the correct settlement method is the most important means of protecting your own interests. There are many options for foreign trade settlement, from the safest T/T (Telegraphic Transfer, prepayment) to the higher-risk D/A (Documents against Acceptance), with varying risks and costs.
I. Overview Comparison of Four Settlement Methods
| Settlement Method | Chinese Name | Risk to Seller | Speed of Fund Arrival | Bank Charges |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T/T (Telegraphic Transfer) | 电汇 | 🟢 Lowest | Fastest | Lowest |
| L/C (Letter of Credit) | 信用证 | 🟡 Medium (with documented compliance) | Medium | Highest |
| D/P (Documents against Payment) | 付款交单 | 🟡 Medium | Medium | Medium |
| D/A (Documents against Acceptance) | 承兑交单 | 🔴 High | Slowest | Medium |
II. T/T (Telegraphic Transfer)
T/T is the most common and safest settlement method – the buyer directly remits the payment to the seller's account through the bank.
Common Payment Modes for T/T
| Mode | Process | Suitable Scenario |
|---|---|---|
| 100% T/T Prepayment | Full payment before shipment | Small orders, first-time cooperation |
| 30% deposit + 70% against copy of B/L | Pay 30% before shipment, pay 70% upon receiving the B/L copy | ✅ Most common, safe and balanced |
| 30% deposit + 70% before arrival at port | Pay 30% before shipment, 70% before arrival at the port | Buyer-friendly, but slightly higher risk for the seller |
T/T Process
Buyer → Bank Transfer → Seller's Bank Receives → Seller Confirms Receipt → Ship / Send Documents
Advantages and Disadvantages of T/T
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Simple operation, no complex bank procedures required | Bank telegraphic transfer fees charged on both ends |
| Fast fund arrival (1-3 business days) | First-time buyers may not be trusting (required to pay upfront) |
| Low cost (fixed wire transfer fee) | — |
III. L/C (Letter of Credit)
L/C is a settlement method with the bank acting as an intermediary guarantor – the buyer's bank promises that as long as the seller submits documents conforming to the L/C terms, the bank must make the payment.
L/C Process
① Both parties agree to settle by L/C
② Buyer applies to the bank to open a letter of credit
③ The issuing bank sends the L/C to the seller's advising bank
④ The seller reviews L/C terms, confirms they are correct, and then ships the goods
⑤ The seller submits the full set of documents to the bank
⑥ The bank checks documents for compliance → pays the seller
Core Principle of L/C: Compliance
The most important requirement for L/C settlement is: the submitted documents must fully comply with the L/C terms. Invoice amount, product description, bill of lading requirements, insurance requirements – if any item does not conform, the bank has the right to refuse payment.
Advantages and Disadvantages of L/C
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Guaranteed by bank credit, reduces the risk of buyer non-payment | High bank costs (issuance fee + advising fee + negotiation fee) |
| Security for large-value transactions | Strict document requirements, easy to create discrepancies |
| Trade finance is possible (packing loan, export negotiation) | Complex process, long turnaround time |
IV. D/P (Documents against Payment)
D/P is a settlement method where the seller controls title documents like the bill of lading through the bank – the buyer must fully pay the invoice before the bank hands over documents such as the B/L to the buyer.
D/P Process
Seller ships goods → Submits full set of documents to bank → Bank notifies buyer of payment
→ Buyer pays the full amount → Bank hands over documents to buyer → Buyer picks up goods with documents
Advantages and Disadvantages of D/P
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Cannot get B/L without payment (controls the goods) | If buyer does not pick up goods, costs accumulate at the port |
| Lower cost than L/C | Buyer credit risk still exists |
| Relatively simple operation | No bank credit guarantee |
V. D/A (Documents against Acceptance)
D/A is the most unfavorable method for the seller among the four – the buyer only needs to "promise to pay in the future" (acceptance) to receive the B/L and pick up the goods. If the buyer refuses to pay after picking up the goods, the seller faces the situation of "losing both goods and money".
D/A Process
Seller ships goods → Hands over documents to bank → Bank notifies buyer →
Buyer signs "acceptance" on the draft → Bank gives documents to buyer for goods pick-up
→ On the due date, buyer does not pay → Seller faces difficulties in collection
Advice for beginner sellers: ❌ Do not use D/A. It seems convenient, but the risk is very high – once the buyer doesn't pay after picking up the goods, recourse is extremely difficult.
VI. Settlement Method Selection Advice for Beginner Sellers
| Scenario | Recommended Method | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Small First Order | 100% T/T Prepayment | Small amount, risk is manageable |
| Large First Order | T/T (30% deposit + 70% against B/L copy) | Most reliable balanced plan |
| Long-term Client | T/T (Monthly or Quarterly Settlement) | Solid trust foundation |
| Large Value Order (>$50,000) | L/C or T/T Partial Payment | Large transactions need more guarantees |
| Buyer requests | L/C (Bank Guarantee) or Refuse | Don't accept if you`re not familiar |
| Any Situation | ❌ Avoid using D/A | Risk is disproportionate to any reward |
VII. Foreign Exchange Management Basics
Foreign trade enterprises need to understand China's foreign exchange management policies when receiving and settling payments.
Key Points
| Point | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Legal Income | Proceeds from export of goods are current account income and can be converted legally |
| Bank Settlement | After receiving foreign currency, can settle with the bank (convert FX to RMB) at the daily rate |
| FX Account | Enterprises with import/export rights can open foreign currency accounts and choose their own settlement timing |
| Limit Management | Under current policies, current account FX income has voluntary settlement (enterprise decides whether and when to settle) |
| Trade Credit Report | Advance receipts or deferred receipts need to file a trade credit report via the SAFE system |
Foreign exchange policies change from time to time. For specific operations, consult the foreign exchange business department of your bank. Compliant collection is the foundation of safe operations.
International Trade Finance
When a company needs working capital, it can use the following trade finance tools:
| Financing Method | Explanation | Applicable Scenario |
|---|---|---|
| Packing Loan | Apply for a loan from the bank based on L/C to prepare goods for production | Received L/C but lack production funds |
| Export Negotiation | Apply for early payment from a bank against documents like B/L | Want to collect payment early after shipping |
| Forfaiting | Sell future accounts receivable to the bank | Large, long-term accounts receivable |
VIII. Common Foreign Trade Frauds & Prevention
| Fraud Type | Identifying Feature | Preventive Action |
|---|---|---|
| Fake Payment Slip | Buyer says "Already transferred" but money hasn't arrived | Must confirm money in account before shipping / releasing documents |
| L/C Soft Clauses | L/C contains hidden, unreasonable clauses | Carefully review clauses upon receiving L/C |
| FOB Designated Freight Forwarder Fraud | Buyer’s nominated forwarder releases goods without original B/L | Verify forwarder qualifications, use actual shipper's B/L where possible |
| D/A – Pick Up Goods, Don`t Pay | Buyer goes missing after picking up goods | Refuse D/A |
💡 Receiving payment is the last and most critical step in foreign trade. The basic principle: Collect payment before shipping goods (or at least collect a deposit before shipping), letting the credit of a professional bank back you up.
📞 Need coordination for settlement and logistics? BF Logistics can handle logistics operations for various settlement methods. Hotline: 13075678958 | info@zhbfwl.com
Related Logistics Services
Bofeng Logistics offers the following related services, feel free to inquire: